Sigi Concept feder
Reviewed by Tyler.
- Overall length: 135 cm / 53 in
- Blade length: 101 cm / 39.7 in
- Handle: 26 cm / 10.2 in
- Pommel: 7cm / 2.8 in
- Schilt width: 6.5cm / 2.6 in
- POB: 6 cm / 2.3 in
- Crossguard: 28 cm / 11-11.8 in
- Flexibility: 12.5 kg / 27.5 lbs
- Weight: 1580g / 3.5 lbs
Ordering and shipping (to Australia)
SIGI Forge is based in Slovakia and so there is a bit of a trek to get it to Australia. They offered a few payment options: Wise, Revolut, Credit/Debit Card, bank transfer or paypal.
SIGI recommended Revolut for outside EU (less fees I believe) and I tried to make an account on these but they were a lot of hassle. I tried bank transfer as well but my bank flagged the purchase as suspicious so I ended up going through Paypal (the most expensive options with the fees) which processed almost immediately. The invoice and proof of payment was swiftly sent to me and then it was time to hurry up and wait.
It took exactly 6 months (to the day) from receipt of payment for my order to be shipped. A faster than average time in this day and age.
Shipping was about €120 on top of the price due to me “choosing” FedEx (it was their only international option) and it took 5 days to arrive. All things considered, a very smooth experience comparative to other manufacturers.
Design
The construction of the sword is exemplary and when you hold one in your hands you can feel that extra level of luxury that SIGI charges for. The pommel is customisable to fit your preference, you can add rings to the cross guard, change the colour and material of the handle as well as the ability to choose if the handle is “waisted” (the handle tapers down from around the bottom third of the handle to the pommel).
I went with the standard length, a red cord wrapping with a waisted handle as my customisation.The cord wrapping is excellent and has not loosened or shifted noticeably at any point in my time using it and is kind to both hand and glove to hold for extended periods. The cord has just begun to fray but this is unsurprising given the constant use. The onion pommel has a few dings but has not come loose and does not rattle at any point.
Practical Observations
The blade is stiff enough to hold up in the bind but is perhaps not the greatest for fuhlen. The point of balance, however, allows for swift and concise movement and transition through guards and from defence to attack.
Where the SIGI really shines, in my opinion, is in the thrust. It’s incredibly responsive to minute wrist manoeuvring allowing for accurate point precision and with its flex at 12.5kg I can thrust with little worries, knowing I will not injure my opponent.
The Main Draw
Of course you can’t talk about the SIGI Concept without a sizable diatribe on the main draw card of the design, the schilt. The selling point here is that it looks to accurately simulate how an opposing blade would move on a longsword as compared to a historical feder while protecting the gloved thumb of the user when it is used in thumb grip.
Before this I had actually used a feder with a “traditional” schilt, the points sticking out to either side. The SIGI concept has its schilt go down to the crossguard and widen out. At its base it is wider than almost any other schilt on the market. This allows for an incoming blade to slide down the schilt and onto the crossguard which, it is argued, is much more historically accurate to the actions of historical longsword on longsword actions when compare to the “historical feder” style of blades that are popular in the HEMA community. This change can help with many counter and thrust style techniques that ask you to cover yourself with the opposing sword having slid down to your strong for control or when needing to lock the opposing blade between your own blade and the crossguard. The extra width also helps protect your thumb in thumb grip even when wearing hard shell gloves, although I’ve been informed it (just barely) fails to fully cover the thumb on the SPES Lobster Heavies, The extra steel at the base also helps with blocks as there is more mass to stand up to the force of a cut.
Summary
After 1 and a half years of continuous use in multiple trainings a week and in 5 tournaments it still remains solid and sexy with minimal filing required over its life (for full disclosure I perform monthly light maintenance to re-oil the blade and remove rust when it appears). I expect that it still has another year of solid fighting in it before I would look to replace it. As my go-to blade.
All in all, the SIGI concept is perfect for those who like precise tip control and the modernity that SIGI aims to bring to the scene while remaining faithfully historical to simulating a longsword. Alongside this, the offered custom options give you plenty of ways to make the SIGI visually unique to you and fit more perfectly into your fencing style and that little extra you spend on this in comparison to base models of other manufacturers is worth every cent.
Nike Tiempo in a HEMA context
Reviewed by Luke.
Footwork in HEMA is a combination of toe-strike and heel-strike steps, with lateral and pivoting movements mixed in. The Tiempo delivers good (but not excessive) grip, sufficient insole padding and heel support, and superior lateral support compared to other thin-soled shoes. The Tiempos are on the lighter side of the spectrum, weighing ~270g, compared to the Merrell Trail Glove (Trail running) at ~220g, Asics Gel-Rocket (Volleyball) at ~315g, and Adidas D’Artagnan (Fencing) at ~490g. Every gram on the shoe is well-considered, as the leather uppers on the Tiempo provide more lateral stability than fabric uppers on lighter shoes like Merrell Trails, and the padding (while more subject to personal preference) is quite welcome. Even so, the thinner soles may require some getting used to. Those coming from a more padded cross-training or running shoe will find that you need to be more mindful in a toe-strike gait, especially when moving quickly. Correct lacing for your foot shape is a requirement to achieve solid foot-lockdown but resources for lacing patterns are plentiful online. Arch support is also minimal, in line with most other thin-soled shoes, but not as absent as in barefoot-style footwear.
The current iteration of this boot (Tiempo 9) is at the time of writing retailing for AUD$120 for the Academy version (don’t buy the Club) which is the only tier featuring Indoor Court soles. They are generally rated to last one season (18 weeks) but my current pair is still in good condition after 18 months of semi-regular use (1-2 training sessions per week). Two colorways are available on the official store (Space Purple/White and Metallic Copper/Photon Dust/White) though as with any soccer boot there are many limited runs of various colours and older series can be found on retailers’ websites for significant discounts.
In summary, Indoor soccer boots in general and the Nike Tiempo series specifically are suitable for HEMA on an indoor court surface and can provide distinct advantages over other alternatives.
Pike Armory Black Cayman
Reviewed by Lee.
My Black Cayman federschwert from Pike Armory was my first ever HEMA-related purchase, and it’s seen much use in the two years that I’ve had it. This is a sword that’s well loved in our club, and for good reason.
We’ll start with the specs, and I’ll preface this review with the note that since my Cayman is almost two years old, the measurements are a bit different to the ones currently advertised on the website.
- Blade Length
- Mine: 102.5 cm
- Advertised: 101 cm
- Total Length
- Mine: 134.5 cm
- Advertised: 131 - 134 cm
- Weight
- Mine: 1550 g
- Advertised: ~ 1460 g
- PoB
- Mine: ~ 7.5 cm
- Advertised: ~ 9 cm
The pros
If I had to use one word to describe the Black Cayman, it would be "solid". It’s well balanced and nice to handle, weighty and stiff enough to cut and block comfortably—though still flexy enough to feel safe thrusting. Its weight also gives it a strong ‘presence’ in the bind, and as a result I’ve gained a preference for techniques like duplieren and zucken that allow me to stay there rather than cutting around.
After nearly two years of continuous use, the quality has really held up. I rarely have to file the edges, have yet to need to replace the grip and none of the hardware has come loose. You can buy replacement blades and pommels from Pike but I doubt you’ll need them - I suspect this feder will last a long time.
I love how it looks aesthetically; the only thing that really shows much sign of wear is the blued pommel and quillons, but just what you get from blued hardware. The shape of the schilt tends to deflect cuts really well, though others in the club have made the criticism that it’s too small and their hands will get hit a lot in a thumb grip. I’ve never had this issue myself though.
The cons
That all being said, while the Cayman is fine all round—there aren’t any obvious weaknesses in its performance - there’s no particular area in which it really excels above other feders I’ve used. It’s not that nimble, and I often find myself unable to keep up with many of my opponents in the Krieg, when I go to cut around or use other techniques once in the bind.
My problems wielding the Black Cayman are certainly exacerbated by me being a wee 5’3 (my sword tip has hit the ground unintentionally many, many times); other, taller club members would likely disagree with my criticism, and if you’re bigger and stronger than I am, this may be the perfect feder for you.
The order process
I’m glad that Pike has a proper website now - though payment does feel a little sketchy via direct bank transfer to Russia. My satisfaction with the Black Cayman was enough to make me pull the trigger on an arming sword and their Sidesword No.2 earlier this year as part of a group order with a few other club members, which I may review in the future. We ended up ordering five swords and two daggers in April, one being custom. Our order was completed in early September and we received it mid-October; overall, not a bad time frame. The Pike team were a little cagey (for obvious reasons) about the shipping situation, but were otherwise transparent, helpful and pleasant whenever I had queries.
The bottom line
Would I recommend the Black Cayman feder? Yes.
Well, maybe not if you’re looking for something with a lot of finesse. I think they’re well worth the price, and if you’re looking for a good all-purpose feder that will last, the Black Cayman is an option worth considering.
Krieger Historical Weapons messer
Reviewed by Jim.
- Weight: 745 g (1,53 lb)
- Length: 900mm (35,43”)
- POB: 13 cm (5,12”)
- Blade geometry: Flat bar, like a feder - folded tip
Things I didn’t like about this blade
- The blade geometry is very basic
No distal taper, which means the bend profile isn’t great (bends across the whole length, not just in the top third)
Corners of the blade are around 90deg, meaning they have a tendency to wear a bit faster and cause more pain than if they were rounded like so many ‘feder-style’ blades
- The durability of the furniture
Or more accurately, its fitting. The crossguard became quite loose after only a few bouts and there is now significant rattle & play.
Things I like about this blade
- Performance is great, handling is great
- No frills utilitarian design appeals to me
- Durability is great, except for the loosening of the crossguard
- Price: 185 euro. Great value proposition for an entry level, utilitarian training tool
Would I recommend it?
At this point it’s a hard sell. While it has some great specs, a good price, and is great to use, the looseness of the crossguard after only a short time is a slight concern. This isn’t a huge problem as you can shim the furniture to stop/reduce the rattle, but definitely something to keep in mind. I think I would recommend it with two caveats; buy it as long as you don’t mind addressing a loose crossguard, and with the awareness that it has the tendency to sting.
I’m excited to see what Krieger comes out with in the future!